top of page

Compare the benefits and drawbacks of hard shell and soft shell rooftop tents to help you choose the best option for your camping adventures.

In our Land Rover Defender Rental world of camping and outdoor adventures, roof top tents have gained immense popularity for their convenience and functionality. Two main types, hard shell and soft shell roof top tents, each offer unique features that cater to different preferences and needs of travelers. In this blog post, we will delve into a detailed comparison of hard shell and soft shell roof top tents to help you make an informed decision before your next camping escapade.


Hard Shell Roof Top Tents


Hard Shell Roof Top Tent

Hard shell roof top tents, as the name suggests, come with a sturdy, durable outer shell that provides excellent protection from the elements. Here are some pros and cons associated with hard shell roof top tents:


Pros:


  • Durability : Hard shell tents are known for their robust construction, making them ideal for rough terrains and challenging weather conditions.

  • Easy Setup : These tents usually have a simple pop-up mechanism, allowing for quick and hassle-free setup.

  • Insulation : The hard shell provides better insulation compared to soft shell tents, making them suitable for cold climates.

  • Security : The rigid structure of hard shell tents offers enhanced security and protection against potential intruders.


Cons:


  • Heavier : Hard shell tents are generally heavier than soft shell tents, affecting your vehicle's gas mileage and overall load capacity.

  • Limited Space : Due to their fixed structure, hard shell tents might have limited interior space compared to soft shell tents.

  • Cost : Hard shell roof top tents often come with a higher price tag compared to soft shell options.


Soft Shell Roof Top Tents


Soft Shell Roof Top Tent

Soft shell roof top tents, on the other hand, are characterized by their fabric-based construction, offering a different set of advantages and disadvantages:


Pros:


  • Lightweight : Soft shell tents are generally lighter, making them more fuel-efficient and suitable for smaller vehicles.

  • Compact : These tents are collapsible and compact when packed, providing more flexibility in terms of storage and transportation.

  • Affordability : Soft shell roof top tents are usually more budget-friendly compared to hard shell options.

  • Expandable : Some soft shell tents come with annexes or extensions, adding extra living space for a more comfortable camping experience.


Cons:


  • Limited Insulation : Soft shell tents may not offer the same level of insulation as hard shell tents, which can be a drawback in extreme weather conditions.

  • Setup Time : Setting up a soft shell tent might take longer compared to hard shell tents, requiring more effort and time.

  • Security : The fabric material of soft shell tents may be more vulnerable to potential damage or break-ins compared to hard shell tents.


Conclusion


Both hard shell and soft shell roof top tents as off road camping gear have their own set of advantages and drawbacks, appealing to different camping styles and preferences. When choosing between the two, it's essential to consider factors such as durability, weight, insulation, setup convenience, and budget. Ultimately, the "best" tent depends on your specific needs and camping habits.


Whether you opt for the rugged dependability of a hard shell roof top tent or the versatility of a soft shell tent, both types offer a unique camping experience that brings you closer to nature while providing a comfortable and secure retreat under the stars.


Next time you plan your outdoor adventure, keep in mind the differences between hard shell and soft shell roof top tents to ensure a memorable and stress-free camping experience. We certainly saw its application in both scenarios hence why our two seater has a hard-shell rooftop tent and why our 4 seater has two soft-shell tents.


What would be your priority? convenience over aesthetics? Let us know.


Happy camping!

@PROJECTWALKABOUT

0 comments

Comentarios


bottom of page